Article 5213

Title of the article



Kosharnyy Valeriy Pavlovich, Doctor of philosophy, professor, head of sub-department of philosophy,
Penza State University (Penza, 40 Krasnaya str.),

Index UDK

 1 (091)


The subject of the article is consideration of the original, for its time, method of historic-philosophical analysis applied by the famous Russian philosopher E. V. de Roberti, and the results thereof. Due to the fact that philosophy is the product and the integral part of the social culture, it is included into the range of phenomena, studied by sociology and is considered as any other fact of social development. Parallel study of the history of special sciences and various form of philosophy is an important methodological purpose of any historical and methodological research. Substantiation of the sociological approach to the history of philosophy is an important contribution to the development of methodology of historical and philosophical research, as well as the discovery by the thinker of an empirical law of metaphysical systems occurrence and a general law of philosophy development. The author concludes that after raising an extremely important and interesting problem of methodology of historical and philosophical research, de Roberti remained within the limits of positivistic world outlook that impeded his consecutive realization of heuristic potential exsiting in the concept of the sociological approach.

Key words

philosophy evolution, law of three types of metaphysics, history of philosophy from sociological point of view, empirical law of metaphysical systems occurence, physical-chemical, organic and superorganic factors, anstract sociology, «pure theoretical knowledge».

Download PDF

1. Volodin A. I., Itenberg B. S. Voprosy filosofii [Philosophy problems]. 1975, no. 3, pp. 108–118.
2. Emel'yanov B. V. Al'manakh «Diskurs-PI», vyp. 3 [Literary miscellany “Discourse-Pi”, issue 3]. Available at:
3. Semlali Yu., Rubanov B. L. Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya [Sociological research]. 2006, no. 8, pp. 139–148.
4. Golosenko I. A. Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya [Sociological research]. 2001, no. 2, pp. 99–107.
5. Buzuk L. G. Vestnik MGOU. Seriya «Filosofskie nauki» [MGOU bulletin. “Philosophical research” series]. 2009, no. 2, pp. 170–179.
6. Kareev N. Osnovy russkoy sotsiologii [Fundamentals of Russian sociology]. Saint Petersburg, 1996.
7. Roberti E. Proshedshee filosofii. Opyt sotsiologicheskogo issledovaniya obshchikh zakonov razvitiya filosofskoy mysli. Obshchedostupnoe izdanie v odnom tome [Philosophical past. Experience of sociological research of general laws of philosophical thought development. Open access issue in single volume]. Moscow: Tipografiya V. V. Islen'eva, 1887, 503 p.
8. Roberti de E. V. Russkaya vysshaya shkola obshchestvennykh nauk v Parizhe: lektsii professorov[Russian higher school of social sciences in Paris: professors’ lections]. Saint Petersburg: G. F. L'vovich, 1905, pp. 32–57.


Дата создания: 13.10.2014 08:17
Дата обновления: 14.10.2014 13:09